Monitoring Design: Stormwater Management Process Visualization and Evaluation
Award of Excellence
Huaiyu ZHOU, Student ASLA
Faculty Advisors: Hailong LIU, International ASLA; Haifeng JIA
"This extraordinary research project represents a significant step forward in providing tools to landscape architects to actively monitor the real-time effectiveness of stormwater management strategies that go well beyond simulations and standard calculations. The research, which used a variety of monitoring devices and sensors tied into a solar-powered wireless network, evaluated the effect on runoff of canopy trees and bioretention basins and established a model for science-based post-occupancy evaluations. As stormwater management and designing for resilience becomes more important, the collection of performance data becomes invaluable, not just so that effective solutions can be created, but to build support among owners and the public for the work of the profession."
- 2019 Awards Jury
- Huiquan JIANG
- Zijing LIU
Construction and Equipment Support：
- LIM Kok Sian, Yu SHANG, and Chang Yi-Chang from Smart Spongy City Lab, Tsinghua University;
- Lang TANG，Jiangqiong PAN and Kun ZHAO from Campus Renovation Mangement Center, Tsinghua University;
- Jianxin YANG and Shuangshou LI from iCenter (Fundamental Industry Training Center), Tsinghua University.
In stormwater management, monitoring analysis is much more accurate than hydrological calculations or simulations. For performance evaluation, high-precision data is needed but hard to come by.
Aiming to find out how much runoff can be reduced by canopy trees, lawn, and bioretention basins with different levels of rainfall, this research uses a wireless sensor network to visualize the whole rainfall process of a closed-watershed campus site named Shengyinyuan. Quantitative performance assessment has also been achieved with the minute-level data collected.
This study provides a set of monitoring indicators and methods for rainwater management which has great potential for more applications and can help landscape architects to evaluate post occupancy. On the other hand, the rainfall process visualization works are good materials for education.
In the 11 rainfall events monitored in the site, canopy trees contributed more than 32% of the interception, and 4 bioretention basins achieved obvious runoff reduction especially in continuous, large and short, high-intensity rainfall events（nearly 10% runoff reduced by 2% area）. Several important results indicated further design improvement.
Background and questions
The last few years have seen an increasing number of stormwater management projects worldwide, but refined monitoring and real process visualization for landscape projects are rare. Since monitoring analysis is much more accurate than traditional methods (hydrological calculations or simulations), we can know much more about the real rainfall process with a network of sensors.
The application of sensors and wireless networks makes it possible to monitor, analyze and evaluate landscape projects dynamically. Landscape architects can not only create space, but also carry out scientific research and performance evaluation by monitoring design.
In order to complete the process visualization and performance evaluation of stormwater management, this study collected at one-minute intervals data of precipitation, interception, evaporation, soil water storage, infiltration and overflow in a closed watershed site.
Shengyinyuan,the monitoring site, is a campus green space which can be seen as an endorheic basin (58848sf). 62% of the site is covered by 4 kinds of canopy trees. Due to the serious waterlogging problems after rainfall events, 4 bioretention gardens were designed to reduce surface runoff.
Monitoring design in this site should avoid affecting the normal use of the space and all the sensors need independent outdoor solar power supply (12V) for safety reasons.
To visualize the real rainfall process for deep understanding and landscape education.
The rainfall process under experimental or simulated conditions is often quite different from the real scene. Real-time monitoring data helps landscape architects to understand various types of rainfall, interception of different canopy trees, soil water storage, and infiltration. Real rainfall process visualization works are the best teaching materials.
To assess the performance for better design.
Differences between the pre-design simulation and the actual runoff reduction are quite inevitable and monitoring can reflect shortcomings in the design clearly. Monitoring system in this site was mainly used to determine whether the location and the capacity of 4 bioretention basins are reasonable.
Research methods and monitoring system design
There is an obvious pattern of rainwater management in this site: rainfall—canopy interception—multiple surfaces runoff—bioretention basins reduction—overflow to water tank. Different sensors are used to monitor the flow reduction of all these stages except runoff generation of multiple surfaces which is hard to measure.
- Precipitation and interception: infrared rain gauge.
- Bioretention basins: water level sensors, soil moisture sensors and infiltration collecting installations.
- Overflow: Open channel flowmeters with a parshall flume connected to an underground water tank.
All the sensors mentioned are powered by outdoor solar panels and battery. Data is actively collected by Data Transfer unit（DTU）after script programming and sent to a cloud server via LTE 4G network. Then the data is decoded and stored in the database.
In addition to the design of the monitoring devices, signal acquisition, data transmission, database programming and system construction are also very important in this study which requires cross-disciplinary research capabilities of landscape architects.
The construction of the system took 2 months and was finished by August 30, 2018, so it has been operating for almost 8 months. Removing abnormal data, the monitoring system has collected a total of 11 rainfall events (data of several events are incomplete due to power supply problems).Data of rianfall,temperature, humidity and PM 2.5 will keep updating on the project webpage:www.xysmartla.com:8050.
Conclusions about canopy interception:
- Canopy trees affected the spatial and temporal distribution of the rainfall events on the site evidently, and for the 11 rainfall events monitored, total canopy interception ratio is 32.7%, holding nearly 25600 gals of runoff.
- Comparison of the 4 species: Salix matsudana Koidz. (67%)> Sophora japonica Linn. (52%) > Populus lasiocarpa Oliv. (50%) >Paulownia fortune (36%).
- Canopy rainfall occured earlier under the tiny blade trees like willow and scholar trees, but they intercepted more in total because of their high canopy density.
Conclusions about the 4 bioretention basins in the site：
- Even in the same site, there is a significant difference in soil moisture distribution of the bioretention basins, and in actual rainfall events, even open basins have specific runoff directions, which can be accurately identified by monitoring.
- The bioretention basins in this site played a significant role in collecting and reducing runoff under heavy rainfall and short, high-intensity rainfall events. In the cases of long-time small rainfalls, the effect of the basins is not obvious, while canopy trees and lawn intercept more than 95% of the runoff.
- Under different rainfall conditions, bioretention basin No. 2 always collected a large amount of external runoff effectively. Larger amounts of outside runoff were reduced by basin No. 4 during heavier rainfall events (rainfall > 0.3 inch).
- Although the target runoff collection areas and the spatial locations are quite similar, basin No. 1 responded much less to runoff than No. 2. More data is needed to finally define whether the capacity of No. 1 is too large.
- The poor overall performance of basin No. 3 reflects the problem of its capacity design and site selection. Further design improvement is needed to optimize this area.
- A set of monitoring indicators and methods for rainwater management are provided which have great potential for more applications in landscape architecture, encouraging landscape architects to design for monitoring in early stages of different projects.
- Images of rainfall process restoration are good materials for landscape and hydrology education. More and more materials will be updated as the system operates continually.
- Accuracy is improved, monitoring period is lengthened, and maintenance costs are reduced with the methods of online monitoring.