Award of Excellence

Sh*tscape: Mumbai’s Landscape In-Between

Bret Betnar, Student ASLA, University of Pennsylvania
Faculty Advisors: Anuradha Mathur, ASLA, Dilip da Cunha

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Site Plan
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 1 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Survey Data taken from Rajesh Gill’s “Slums as Urban Villages”
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 2 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Mumbai
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 3 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    This project will propose the making of an entirely functioning landscape built from human excreta. It will recover the ‘soil’ from the settlements while extracting the beneficial flora from the forest and, in turn, utilize both as a generator for a new and evolving landscape. It will be directed at relieving the conditions of poverty where those living in this peri-urban zone will be the agents of change as they participate in the creation, processing and profits of this landscape.
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 4 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    The Appapada Quarry separates the established neighborhood of Malad East and a hillside of informal settlements. In the middle of the quarry is the large Appapada Maidan, used by kids and adults from varying parts of northern Mumbai. Several areas in and around the quarry environs are used for toileting by the local populace (above and opposite, in grey).
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 5 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    ‘Sh*tscape’ proposes three major introductory insertions: constructed trench-like composting toilets, a stone pathway traversing the quarry wall and stone ‘tanks’ for the retention of water. Other minor insertions should include a slow-sand filter for availability of potable water, a grove of both coconuts and bananas to help begin the functioning of the landscape and pit toilets for use during the monsoon season.
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 6 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    With water, improved soil, food supplies and the resiliency of the local population, this landscape can evolve throughout time to accommodate more varieties of produce and the potentially profitable growing of timber and Ayurvedic plant material. Additions to the water and toilet systems can be made as required by the local community. If this landscape is to be a success, it will need not only the inputs from the community, but their ingenuity in adapting the plan to their own uses. As such, it is hoped that this landscape could be maintained through multi-family networks, much like a village system. This project is designed as a prototype scenario which, if successful, could be repeated elsewhere along the western edge of the park.
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 7 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    These graphs represent a temporal evolution of the site: I) toileting/composting process; II) development of site’s water and pedestrian infrastructure; III) special cultivations, primarily food; IV) economic-generating Ayurvedic and forest plants.
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 8 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Top: Site Evolution Composite Bottom: Proposed Site Ciruclation with Surface Water System
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 9 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Evolution: Composting Process
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 10 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Insertion: Infrastructure Typologies
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 11 of 12

  • Sh*tscape: Mumbai's Landscape In-Between
    Close Me!

    Extraction: Planting Scheme
    Download Hi-Res Image

    Photo: Bret Betnar

    Photo 12 of 12

Project Statement

A growing number of the world’s population has little or no access to sanitation. This is particularly prevalent in India, where over 750 million people are without adequate sanitation facilities. Few designers have attempted to grapple with this ‘dirty’ subject. Sh*tscape: Mumbai’s Landscape In-Between proposes the making of an entirely functioning landscape built from human excreta. It will recover the ‘soil’ from the settlements while extracting the beneficial flora from the forest and, in turn, utilize both as a generator for a new and evolving landscape.

Project Narrative

Introduction

Sh*tscape, Mumbai’s Landscape In-Between focuses on the Appapada Quarry in the northern Mumbai suburb of Malad East. It addresses the issue of informal settlements and sanitation at the western boundary of Sanjay Gandhi National Park. This project will propose the making of an entirely functioning landscape built from human excreta. It will recover the ‘soil’ from the settlements while extracting the beneficial flora from the forest and, in turn, utilize both as a generator for a new and evolving landscape. It will be directed at relieving the conditions of poverty where those living in this peri-urban zone will be the agents of change as they participate in the creation, processing and profits of this landscape.

The Appapada Quarry separates the established neighborhood of Malad East and a hillside of informal settlements.  In the middle of the quarry is the large Appapada Maidan, used by kids and adults from varying parts of northern Mumbai.  Several areas in and around the quarry environs are used for toileting by the local populace.

Insertion

Sh*tscape proposes three major introductory insertions: constructed trench-like composting toilets, a stone pathway traversing the quarry wall and stone ‘tanks’ for the retention of water. Other minor insertions should include a slow-sand filter for availability of potable water, a grove of both coconuts and bananas to help begin the functioning of the landscape and pit toilets for use during the monsoon season. 

Extraction

With water, improved soil, food supplies and the resiliency of the local population, this landscape can evolve throughout time to accommodate more varieties of produce and the potentially profitable growing of timber and Ayurvedic plant material. Additions to the water and toilet systems can be made as required by the local community as it grows and formalizes.

If this landscape is to be a success, it will need not only the inputs from the community, but their ingenuity in adapting the plan to their own uses.  As such, it is hoped that this landscape could be maintained through multi-family networks, much like a village system.  This project is designed as a prototype scenario which, if successful, could be repeated elsewhere along the western edge of the park.

Additional Project Credits

Sunjoy Monga

Kavita Khanna

The People of Mumbai
Mumbai Studio Mates

University of Pennsylvania Department of Landscape Architecture

The Trident/Oberoi
Hare Rama Hare Krishna Mandir

Aaron Kelley and Carlos